| Highlights and Commentary |
| By Roy Weitz |

The FundAlarm Hatchling Report: This month's FundAlarm database contains 199 funds that completed their first full year in 2000.....And how did they perform?.....It's difficult to generalize, because there are relatively few funds in some categories (for example, only two new balanced funds, and one new utilities fund).....But in the two categories with the largest number of new funds (technology and large-cap), the new funds generally performed worse than older funds.....For example, 52% of the new technology funds (35 of 67) underperformed our technology fund benchmark for 2000, compared with only 47% of the older tech funds.....Likewise, 54% of the new large-cap funds (29 of 53) underperformed our large cap benchmark for 2000, versus only 42% of the funds that were around before 2000.....As we said, the results are inconclusive, but at least one thing was clear in 2000: Contrary to a widely-held belief, new funds were not the path to sure and easy riches.....The accompanying pages present all 199 new funds, sorted in two different ways: alphabetically by benchmark, and performance-ranked by benchmark.....Just for fun, here's a list of the very best and worst new funds for 2000, by benchmark category (categories with fewer than 10 new funds are omitted):| Benchmark category | Best new fund for 2000/ (total return %) | Worst new fund for 2000/ (total return %) |
|---|---|---|
| Large-cap | AIM Large Cap Oppty A (LCPAX) +30.86% | OpenFund (OPENX) -41.93% |
| Mid-cap | Franklin U.S. Long-Short (FUSLX) +55.08% | H&Q IPO & Emerging Co B (HIPBX) -49.53% |
| International | Deutsche Europe Eqty Inv (MEUVX) +86.98% | Dreyfus Founders Passport B (FPSBX) -30.05% |
| Specialty-Health | Evergreen Health Care A (EHABX) +119.05% | Alliance Health Care C (AHLCX) +30.43% |
| Specialty-Tech | Potomac Internet/Short +59.4% | Jacob Internet (JAMFX) -79.11% |
Robert Mohn runs Liberty Acorn USA Fund.....In a recent interview with CBS.MarketWatch.com, Mohn said that he and his team pride themselves on "finding that special stock before it's discovered by the rest of the crowd".....Mohn proceeded to identify three of his favorite "sleeper stocks": ITT Educational Services (ESI), Telephone and Data Systems Inc. (TDS), and National Data Corp (NDC).....Let's take a closer look:
If you've ever done any retirement planning (online or off), you know how it usually works: A computer program asks for your age, assets, required monthly income, and an assumed rate of investment return.....Then, the program crunches some numbers, and it tells you whether or not you'll be able to meet your income goal.....Retirement models like this are inflexible, especially the way they handle investment returns, and that's their biggest drawback, .....For example, say you assume an average investment return of 12% over a 30-year retirement....In the real world, of course, an average return of 12% doesn't mean that every year will come in at 12% -- some years will generate much higher returns, and some much lower.....If the early years of your retirement include several low-return years, you could run out of money much sooner than 30 years, even though the average 30-year return might still be 12%.
Where did we get the data that we use in the T. Rowe Price retirement model, above?.....Charles Schwab has a new book, You're Fifty-Now What?, and there's one part of the book that's getting a lot of media attention.....It's Schwab's "Guideline of 230K" (page 48), which goes like this:| "For every $1,000 you'll need each month [during retirement], you should have at least $230,000 invested when you stop working." |
And here's a retirement planner that's really depressing:

As democratic institutions go, mutual funds leave much to be desired.....But at least fund shareholders have the power to approve or disapprove any new fund manager.....Right?.....Wrong.....In the typical structure, fund directors hire an investment advisor to run the fund's investment operations, and the fund manager is an employee of the investment advisor.....If the fund's directors want to hire a new advisor/manager, shareholders must approve.....However, certain funds operate under what's called a multimanager exemption, which is granted by the SEC on a case-by-case basis.....A multimanager fund (such as Master's Select Equity) is still technically run by an investment advisor, but that advisor usually doesn't have any role in the day-to-day selection of investments.....Instead, the advisor farms out the investment work to one or more subadvisors, who actually run the fund (in the case of Master's Select, the advisor is Litman/Gregory, and the subadvisors include Mason Hawkins, Bill Miller, and Sig Segalas).....When a fund with a multimanager exemption wants to fire or hire a subadvisor/manager, shareholder approval isn't required.
The slogans of most mutual fund companies are bland, harmless, and completely unmemorable.....Occasionally, however, a fund company slogan is so ridiculous, and so inappropriate, you'd think that even the marketing people might have some second thoughts about using it.....Consider, for example, the following juxtaposition, which recently appeared on the PBHG Home page:
And what does McCaffrey have to say about "The Rewards of Time"?| "In building the portfolio [remember: 1,000% turnover], we attempt to balance a company's long-term growth potential and near-term business results with the valuation it commands in the market.*" |
Last month, we ran a brief item about the Mainstay Equity Index fund.....We marveled that this load fund (3%) with an exorbitant expense ratio (0.94%) could still manage to attract $1.2 billion in assets, especially when index fund investors have so many less expensive alternatives.....After the item appeared, several FundAlarm readers pointed out that this Mainstay fund comes with an unusual money-back guarantee, which is described in the prospectus as follows:| "...If, ten years from your date of purchase, the net asset value of a unit [with dividends reinvested] is less than the price you initially paid for the Fund share, NYLIFE will pay you the difference between the price you paid and the value of a unit." |
Benjamin Graham is widely regarded as the father of value investing, so it was somewhat surprising to see his name invoked in Jim Goff's year-end letter to shareholders of Janus Enterprise, a growth fund if there ever was one:| "Benjamin Graham, perhaps the most famous practitioner of the fundamentally-based, company-by-company approach we follow, once said that 'In the short-term, the market is a voting machine, and in the long-term, it's a weighing machine.' Ultimately, we believe the strong earnings growth each of our holdings is capable of delivering will tip the scales in our favor." | ||
| --Thanks to FundAlarm reader William Cornwell, of Fredericksburg, VA, for bringing this item to our attention | ||
Benjamin Graham responds:![]()
|
|
And now, perhaps, it's time for some grief counseling:| "I think [Internet stocks] are fairly close to the bottom. We've gone through massive consolation." | |||
|
---Paul Meeks, manager of Merrill Lynch Internet Strategies fund, quoted (we hope incorrectly) at Worth.com | |||
Charles Schwab (the person) is one of the main reasons that Charles Schwab (the company) has been so successful, and Schwab-the-person is prominently featured in much of the media produced by his company.....These days, "content" is one of the company's main strategic initiatives, which means that online Schwab newsletters, classes, and financial shows are ultimately designed not to feed your brain, but to hustle Schwab products.....As the leading spokesman for the Schwab brand name, the "polite, personable, and genteel" Chuck Schwab has even been compared to Walt Disney.....Now, Schwab's company faces the morbid question of what to do when its namesake eventually passes on to that great trading floor in the sky:| "Like Disney's, Schwab's name will live on long after his death. It's also easy to see how Schwab's company could continue to use his image after he's gone, just as Disney sometimes comes in handy or a cartoon version of Colonel Sanders still flogs chicken on television. Some Schwab executives have even discussed, only half-kiddingly, the idea of creating a 2-D version of Schwab -- the 'autoChuck' -- that would pop up to help confused users in much the same way that Microsoft's annoying 'paper clip guy' comes to the rescue."* |
EXCLUSIVE! FundAlarm has obtained an early version of Schwab's "AutoChuck"!
Briefly noted:
![]() Not your fund | "Loyalty, tenacity, and optimism are great human characteristics, but when they are applied to the wrong object of affection -- your mutual fund -- they can be a problem. There is no reciprocity. A fund is like one of those robot dogs. You can lavish it with attention but get nothing -- not even a lick on the hand -- in return." |
![]() | "Johnson has a quirky side that the public rarely gets to see. He and Curvey [another Fidelity exec] used to travel around the country and drop in on employees at Fidelity investor centers. They'd drop in on rivals too, to check out the competition. More than once, the two would stop at a Charles Schwab & Co. brokerage office and 'ask to see Chuck,' Curvey confesses, much to the dismay of the confused employees."* |